Disable prompt for authentication on autocompletion of a command which needs root privileges

The name of the pictureThe name of the pictureThe name of the pictureClash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP











up vote
4
down vote

favorite
1












When I use e.g. firewall-cmd, which correctly needs root privileges to execute, I get prompted in a window (so not in the terminal as with sudo) to give my password when I try to autocomplete an option (e.g. write "--perm" and hit TAB). This happens every time I use autocompletion, even if I already entered my password before and/or ran a command with sudo (which is configured to not prompt me a second time for a certain time).



Is there any way to either make entering the password permanent for a certain time or complete disable authentication for mere autocompletion (I still want authentication for actually running the program)?



The obvious solution is to login as root (use su or sudo -i), but I'd like to avoid doing that.



I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard bash_completion file shipped with the bash-completion package in Debian.



I can reproduce this with just . /etc/bash_completion in my .bashrc.



Running complete -p firewall-cmd results in
bash: complete: firewall-cmd: no completion specification



The reason I thought polkit was involved (see original tags) is, that when I abort the authentication dialogue I get the following on stdout:



Authorization failed.
Make sure polkit agent is running or run the application as superuser.









share|improve this question























  • What shell do you use and how is completion configured? The shell is probably invoking the command to list possible completions, but it's weird that it would run sudo. Do you have an alias or function?
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 20:54










  • @Gilles I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard "bash_completion" file shipped with the bash-completion package in debian (upstream is github.com/scop/bash-completion). I didn't think of that: Does the shell have to invoke the actual command for autocompletion? In that case it is clear why I am asked to authenticate (the executable in question needs root privs), but still not clear why entering the password once is not cached for some time.
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 21:55











  • The shell doesn't have to invoke the actual command, but it sometimes does. For example it might invoke the command with --help and parse the output to get the exact list of supported options on that particular version of the command. I don't see anything specific to firewall-cmd in the bash_completion code. Can you reproduce this if your .bashrc contains nothing apart from . /etc/bash_completion? If not, post your .bashrc.
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 22:14










  • @Gilles, icarus: I added this information to the question. Thanks for looking into this!
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 23:05














up vote
4
down vote

favorite
1












When I use e.g. firewall-cmd, which correctly needs root privileges to execute, I get prompted in a window (so not in the terminal as with sudo) to give my password when I try to autocomplete an option (e.g. write "--perm" and hit TAB). This happens every time I use autocompletion, even if I already entered my password before and/or ran a command with sudo (which is configured to not prompt me a second time for a certain time).



Is there any way to either make entering the password permanent for a certain time or complete disable authentication for mere autocompletion (I still want authentication for actually running the program)?



The obvious solution is to login as root (use su or sudo -i), but I'd like to avoid doing that.



I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard bash_completion file shipped with the bash-completion package in Debian.



I can reproduce this with just . /etc/bash_completion in my .bashrc.



Running complete -p firewall-cmd results in
bash: complete: firewall-cmd: no completion specification



The reason I thought polkit was involved (see original tags) is, that when I abort the authentication dialogue I get the following on stdout:



Authorization failed.
Make sure polkit agent is running or run the application as superuser.









share|improve this question























  • What shell do you use and how is completion configured? The shell is probably invoking the command to list possible completions, but it's weird that it would run sudo. Do you have an alias or function?
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 20:54










  • @Gilles I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard "bash_completion" file shipped with the bash-completion package in debian (upstream is github.com/scop/bash-completion). I didn't think of that: Does the shell have to invoke the actual command for autocompletion? In that case it is clear why I am asked to authenticate (the executable in question needs root privs), but still not clear why entering the password once is not cached for some time.
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 21:55











  • The shell doesn't have to invoke the actual command, but it sometimes does. For example it might invoke the command with --help and parse the output to get the exact list of supported options on that particular version of the command. I don't see anything specific to firewall-cmd in the bash_completion code. Can you reproduce this if your .bashrc contains nothing apart from . /etc/bash_completion? If not, post your .bashrc.
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 22:14










  • @Gilles, icarus: I added this information to the question. Thanks for looking into this!
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 23:05












up vote
4
down vote

favorite
1









up vote
4
down vote

favorite
1






1





When I use e.g. firewall-cmd, which correctly needs root privileges to execute, I get prompted in a window (so not in the terminal as with sudo) to give my password when I try to autocomplete an option (e.g. write "--perm" and hit TAB). This happens every time I use autocompletion, even if I already entered my password before and/or ran a command with sudo (which is configured to not prompt me a second time for a certain time).



Is there any way to either make entering the password permanent for a certain time or complete disable authentication for mere autocompletion (I still want authentication for actually running the program)?



The obvious solution is to login as root (use su or sudo -i), but I'd like to avoid doing that.



I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard bash_completion file shipped with the bash-completion package in Debian.



I can reproduce this with just . /etc/bash_completion in my .bashrc.



Running complete -p firewall-cmd results in
bash: complete: firewall-cmd: no completion specification



The reason I thought polkit was involved (see original tags) is, that when I abort the authentication dialogue I get the following on stdout:



Authorization failed.
Make sure polkit agent is running or run the application as superuser.









share|improve this question















When I use e.g. firewall-cmd, which correctly needs root privileges to execute, I get prompted in a window (so not in the terminal as with sudo) to give my password when I try to autocomplete an option (e.g. write "--perm" and hit TAB). This happens every time I use autocompletion, even if I already entered my password before and/or ran a command with sudo (which is configured to not prompt me a second time for a certain time).



Is there any way to either make entering the password permanent for a certain time or complete disable authentication for mere autocompletion (I still want authentication for actually running the program)?



The obvious solution is to login as root (use su or sudo -i), but I'd like to avoid doing that.



I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard bash_completion file shipped with the bash-completion package in Debian.



I can reproduce this with just . /etc/bash_completion in my .bashrc.



Running complete -p firewall-cmd results in
bash: complete: firewall-cmd: no completion specification



The reason I thought polkit was involved (see original tags) is, that when I abort the authentication dialogue I get the following on stdout:



Authorization failed.
Make sure polkit agent is running or run the application as superuser.






bash sudo autocomplete






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Sep 15 at 16:33









Jeff Schaller

33.1k849111




33.1k849111










asked Nov 6 '16 at 19:01









imsodin

1786




1786











  • What shell do you use and how is completion configured? The shell is probably invoking the command to list possible completions, but it's weird that it would run sudo. Do you have an alias or function?
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 20:54










  • @Gilles I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard "bash_completion" file shipped with the bash-completion package in debian (upstream is github.com/scop/bash-completion). I didn't think of that: Does the shell have to invoke the actual command for autocompletion? In that case it is clear why I am asked to authenticate (the executable in question needs root privs), but still not clear why entering the password once is not cached for some time.
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 21:55











  • The shell doesn't have to invoke the actual command, but it sometimes does. For example it might invoke the command with --help and parse the output to get the exact list of supported options on that particular version of the command. I don't see anything specific to firewall-cmd in the bash_completion code. Can you reproduce this if your .bashrc contains nothing apart from . /etc/bash_completion? If not, post your .bashrc.
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 22:14










  • @Gilles, icarus: I added this information to the question. Thanks for looking into this!
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 23:05
















  • What shell do you use and how is completion configured? The shell is probably invoking the command to list possible completions, but it's weird that it would run sudo. Do you have an alias or function?
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 20:54










  • @Gilles I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard "bash_completion" file shipped with the bash-completion package in debian (upstream is github.com/scop/bash-completion). I didn't think of that: Does the shell have to invoke the actual command for autocompletion? In that case it is clear why I am asked to authenticate (the executable in question needs root privs), but still not clear why entering the password once is not cached for some time.
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 21:55











  • The shell doesn't have to invoke the actual command, but it sometimes does. For example it might invoke the command with --help and parse the output to get the exact list of supported options on that particular version of the command. I don't see anything specific to firewall-cmd in the bash_completion code. Can you reproduce this if your .bashrc contains nothing apart from . /etc/bash_completion? If not, post your .bashrc.
    – Gilles
    Nov 6 '16 at 22:14










  • @Gilles, icarus: I added this information to the question. Thanks for looking into this!
    – imsodin
    Nov 6 '16 at 23:05















What shell do you use and how is completion configured? The shell is probably invoking the command to list possible completions, but it's weird that it would run sudo. Do you have an alias or function?
– Gilles
Nov 6 '16 at 20:54




What shell do you use and how is completion configured? The shell is probably invoking the command to list possible completions, but it's weird that it would run sudo. Do you have an alias or function?
– Gilles
Nov 6 '16 at 20:54












@Gilles I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard "bash_completion" file shipped with the bash-completion package in debian (upstream is github.com/scop/bash-completion). I didn't think of that: Does the shell have to invoke the actual command for autocompletion? In that case it is clear why I am asked to authenticate (the executable in question needs root privs), but still not clear why entering the password once is not cached for some time.
– imsodin
Nov 6 '16 at 21:55





@Gilles I am using bash and my .bashrc sources the standard "bash_completion" file shipped with the bash-completion package in debian (upstream is github.com/scop/bash-completion). I didn't think of that: Does the shell have to invoke the actual command for autocompletion? In that case it is clear why I am asked to authenticate (the executable in question needs root privs), but still not clear why entering the password once is not cached for some time.
– imsodin
Nov 6 '16 at 21:55













The shell doesn't have to invoke the actual command, but it sometimes does. For example it might invoke the command with --help and parse the output to get the exact list of supported options on that particular version of the command. I don't see anything specific to firewall-cmd in the bash_completion code. Can you reproduce this if your .bashrc contains nothing apart from . /etc/bash_completion? If not, post your .bashrc.
– Gilles
Nov 6 '16 at 22:14




The shell doesn't have to invoke the actual command, but it sometimes does. For example it might invoke the command with --help and parse the output to get the exact list of supported options on that particular version of the command. I don't see anything specific to firewall-cmd in the bash_completion code. Can you reproduce this if your .bashrc contains nothing apart from . /etc/bash_completion? If not, post your .bashrc.
– Gilles
Nov 6 '16 at 22:14












@Gilles, icarus: I added this information to the question. Thanks for looking into this!
– imsodin
Nov 6 '16 at 23:05




@Gilles, icarus: I added this information to the question. Thanks for looking into this!
– imsodin
Nov 6 '16 at 23:05










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
4
down vote



accepted










Normally to see the completion associated with a command like firewall-cmd one would use complete -p firewall-cmd and expect to see something like complete -F _firewall_cmd firewall-cmd coming back. One would then examine the _firewall_cmd function using type _firewall_cmd.



The bash completion package for Debian uses a complete -D command to set up a default completion function, which looks to see if there is a specific completion available the first time it is used, and if so loads it.



Therefore it is important to attempt completion once before looking to see how completion is set up.



For firewall-cmd this
file defines the completion function which currently starts



_firewall_cmd()
{
local cur prev words cword split
_init_completion -s || return
firewall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return


The /usr/bin/firewall-cmd program itself is a python script, which ends up needing root privileges and asking for authentication. A call of firewall-cmd --state returns true if the firewall is running. The intention of the completion code therefore seems to be to not do completion if the firewall isn't running. However it is written to need the privileges to see if the firewall is running, and this is causing the unwanted prompts.



Deleting the firwall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return line from the completion function makes completion faster, not prompt for password, and other general goodness.






share|improve this answer





























    up vote
    -2
    down vote













    You can use nopasswd option of sudo. Just add nopasswd option in suoders file for your user.



    e.g. if your user name is imosdin, then modify entry in sudoers by executing command visduo, and add/modify below mentioned entry.



    imsodin ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD: ALL


    Now, system will allow imsodin user to execute any command via sudo without prompting for password.






    share|improve this answer




















    • I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
      – imsodin
      Nov 6 '16 at 19:24











    Your Answer







    StackExchange.ready(function()
    var channelOptions =
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "106"
    ;
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
    createEditor();
    );

    else
    createEditor();

    );

    function createEditor()
    StackExchange.prepareEditor(
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: false,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    );



    );













     

    draft saved


    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function ()
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2funix.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f321478%2fdisable-prompt-for-authentication-on-autocompletion-of-a-command-which-needs-roo%23new-answer', 'question_page');

    );

    Post as a guest






























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    4
    down vote



    accepted










    Normally to see the completion associated with a command like firewall-cmd one would use complete -p firewall-cmd and expect to see something like complete -F _firewall_cmd firewall-cmd coming back. One would then examine the _firewall_cmd function using type _firewall_cmd.



    The bash completion package for Debian uses a complete -D command to set up a default completion function, which looks to see if there is a specific completion available the first time it is used, and if so loads it.



    Therefore it is important to attempt completion once before looking to see how completion is set up.



    For firewall-cmd this
    file defines the completion function which currently starts



    _firewall_cmd()
    {
    local cur prev words cword split
    _init_completion -s || return
    firewall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return


    The /usr/bin/firewall-cmd program itself is a python script, which ends up needing root privileges and asking for authentication. A call of firewall-cmd --state returns true if the firewall is running. The intention of the completion code therefore seems to be to not do completion if the firewall isn't running. However it is written to need the privileges to see if the firewall is running, and this is causing the unwanted prompts.



    Deleting the firwall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return line from the completion function makes completion faster, not prompt for password, and other general goodness.






    share|improve this answer


























      up vote
      4
      down vote



      accepted










      Normally to see the completion associated with a command like firewall-cmd one would use complete -p firewall-cmd and expect to see something like complete -F _firewall_cmd firewall-cmd coming back. One would then examine the _firewall_cmd function using type _firewall_cmd.



      The bash completion package for Debian uses a complete -D command to set up a default completion function, which looks to see if there is a specific completion available the first time it is used, and if so loads it.



      Therefore it is important to attempt completion once before looking to see how completion is set up.



      For firewall-cmd this
      file defines the completion function which currently starts



      _firewall_cmd()
      {
      local cur prev words cword split
      _init_completion -s || return
      firewall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return


      The /usr/bin/firewall-cmd program itself is a python script, which ends up needing root privileges and asking for authentication. A call of firewall-cmd --state returns true if the firewall is running. The intention of the completion code therefore seems to be to not do completion if the firewall isn't running. However it is written to need the privileges to see if the firewall is running, and this is causing the unwanted prompts.



      Deleting the firwall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return line from the completion function makes completion faster, not prompt for password, and other general goodness.






      share|improve this answer
























        up vote
        4
        down vote



        accepted







        up vote
        4
        down vote



        accepted






        Normally to see the completion associated with a command like firewall-cmd one would use complete -p firewall-cmd and expect to see something like complete -F _firewall_cmd firewall-cmd coming back. One would then examine the _firewall_cmd function using type _firewall_cmd.



        The bash completion package for Debian uses a complete -D command to set up a default completion function, which looks to see if there is a specific completion available the first time it is used, and if so loads it.



        Therefore it is important to attempt completion once before looking to see how completion is set up.



        For firewall-cmd this
        file defines the completion function which currently starts



        _firewall_cmd()
        {
        local cur prev words cword split
        _init_completion -s || return
        firewall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return


        The /usr/bin/firewall-cmd program itself is a python script, which ends up needing root privileges and asking for authentication. A call of firewall-cmd --state returns true if the firewall is running. The intention of the completion code therefore seems to be to not do completion if the firewall isn't running. However it is written to need the privileges to see if the firewall is running, and this is causing the unwanted prompts.



        Deleting the firwall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return line from the completion function makes completion faster, not prompt for password, and other general goodness.






        share|improve this answer














        Normally to see the completion associated with a command like firewall-cmd one would use complete -p firewall-cmd and expect to see something like complete -F _firewall_cmd firewall-cmd coming back. One would then examine the _firewall_cmd function using type _firewall_cmd.



        The bash completion package for Debian uses a complete -D command to set up a default completion function, which looks to see if there is a specific completion available the first time it is used, and if so loads it.



        Therefore it is important to attempt completion once before looking to see how completion is set up.



        For firewall-cmd this
        file defines the completion function which currently starts



        _firewall_cmd()
        {
        local cur prev words cword split
        _init_completion -s || return
        firewall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return


        The /usr/bin/firewall-cmd program itself is a python script, which ends up needing root privileges and asking for authentication. A call of firewall-cmd --state returns true if the firewall is running. The intention of the completion code therefore seems to be to not do completion if the firewall isn't running. However it is written to need the privileges to see if the firewall is running, and this is causing the unwanted prompts.



        Deleting the firwall-cmd --state 1> /dev/null || return line from the completion function makes completion faster, not prompt for password, and other general goodness.







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited Sep 16 at 22:35

























        answered Nov 12 '16 at 22:03









        icarus

        4,7981725




        4,7981725






















            up vote
            -2
            down vote













            You can use nopasswd option of sudo. Just add nopasswd option in suoders file for your user.



            e.g. if your user name is imosdin, then modify entry in sudoers by executing command visduo, and add/modify below mentioned entry.



            imsodin ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD: ALL


            Now, system will allow imsodin user to execute any command via sudo without prompting for password.






            share|improve this answer




















            • I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
              – imsodin
              Nov 6 '16 at 19:24















            up vote
            -2
            down vote













            You can use nopasswd option of sudo. Just add nopasswd option in suoders file for your user.



            e.g. if your user name is imosdin, then modify entry in sudoers by executing command visduo, and add/modify below mentioned entry.



            imsodin ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD: ALL


            Now, system will allow imsodin user to execute any command via sudo without prompting for password.






            share|improve this answer




















            • I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
              – imsodin
              Nov 6 '16 at 19:24













            up vote
            -2
            down vote










            up vote
            -2
            down vote









            You can use nopasswd option of sudo. Just add nopasswd option in suoders file for your user.



            e.g. if your user name is imosdin, then modify entry in sudoers by executing command visduo, and add/modify below mentioned entry.



            imsodin ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD: ALL


            Now, system will allow imsodin user to execute any command via sudo without prompting for password.






            share|improve this answer












            You can use nopasswd option of sudo. Just add nopasswd option in suoders file for your user.



            e.g. if your user name is imosdin, then modify entry in sudoers by executing command visduo, and add/modify below mentioned entry.



            imsodin ALL=(ALL) NOPASSWD: ALL


            Now, system will allow imsodin user to execute any command via sudo without prompting for password.







            share|improve this answer












            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer










            answered Nov 6 '16 at 19:14









            sssdexp

            1123




            1123











            • I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
              – imsodin
              Nov 6 '16 at 19:24

















            • I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
              – imsodin
              Nov 6 '16 at 19:24
















            I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
            – imsodin
            Nov 6 '16 at 19:24





            I know about that option, but I don't want to give that kind of access. I want authentication including using my password to execute the program, I just don't want to be prompted to give the password whenever I use the autocompletion.
            – imsodin
            Nov 6 '16 at 19:24


















             

            draft saved


            draft discarded















































             


            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function ()
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2funix.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f321478%2fdisable-prompt-for-authentication-on-autocompletion-of-a-command-which-needs-roo%23new-answer', 'question_page');

            );

            Post as a guest













































































            Popular posts from this blog

            How to check contact read email or not when send email to Individual?

            Displaying single band from multi-band raster using QGIS

            How many registers does an x86_64 CPU actually have?