Question on discrepancy between Rambam and Gemara
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
If someone separated the first shearings of wool from his sheep to give to a Kohen, and he loses it, he is responsible to replace it (Rambam, Bikkurim 10,8). Doesn't that contradict the Gemara in Hullin (130b) that someone who damages or eats gifts for the Kohen is exempt from paying because it's money that no one can demand?
rambam chulin-tractate
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
If someone separated the first shearings of wool from his sheep to give to a Kohen, and he loses it, he is responsible to replace it (Rambam, Bikkurim 10,8). Doesn't that contradict the Gemara in Hullin (130b) that someone who damages or eats gifts for the Kohen is exempt from paying because it's money that no one can demand?
rambam chulin-tractate
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
Welcome to Mi Yodeya! Please take a moment to look over our tour where you’ll find useful information about our site. I’ve gone ahead and helped you out with the tags and replaced the more yeshivish terminology you used with wording that’s easier for the layman to understand. If you don’t like any of these changes or want to change more, please feel more than welcome to edit it yourself. Thank you for your insightful question and I hope to see you around!
– DonielF
Aug 17 at 4:35
1
Does the same not apply to Pidyon Haben?
– Double AA♦
Aug 17 at 12:20
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
If someone separated the first shearings of wool from his sheep to give to a Kohen, and he loses it, he is responsible to replace it (Rambam, Bikkurim 10,8). Doesn't that contradict the Gemara in Hullin (130b) that someone who damages or eats gifts for the Kohen is exempt from paying because it's money that no one can demand?
rambam chulin-tractate
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
If someone separated the first shearings of wool from his sheep to give to a Kohen, and he loses it, he is responsible to replace it (Rambam, Bikkurim 10,8). Doesn't that contradict the Gemara in Hullin (130b) that someone who damages or eats gifts for the Kohen is exempt from paying because it's money that no one can demand?
rambam chulin-tractate
rambam chulin-tractate
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
edited Aug 17 at 10:12
Joel K
7,8281461
7,8281461
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
asked Aug 17 at 4:19
user17880
212
212
Welcome to Mi Yodeya! Please take a moment to look over our tour where you’ll find useful information about our site. I’ve gone ahead and helped you out with the tags and replaced the more yeshivish terminology you used with wording that’s easier for the layman to understand. If you don’t like any of these changes or want to change more, please feel more than welcome to edit it yourself. Thank you for your insightful question and I hope to see you around!
– DonielF
Aug 17 at 4:35
1
Does the same not apply to Pidyon Haben?
– Double AA♦
Aug 17 at 12:20
add a comment |Â
Welcome to Mi Yodeya! Please take a moment to look over our tour where you’ll find useful information about our site. I’ve gone ahead and helped you out with the tags and replaced the more yeshivish terminology you used with wording that’s easier for the layman to understand. If you don’t like any of these changes or want to change more, please feel more than welcome to edit it yourself. Thank you for your insightful question and I hope to see you around!
– DonielF
Aug 17 at 4:35
1
Does the same not apply to Pidyon Haben?
– Double AA♦
Aug 17 at 12:20
Welcome to Mi Yodeya! Please take a moment to look over our tour where you’ll find useful information about our site. I’ve gone ahead and helped you out with the tags and replaced the more yeshivish terminology you used with wording that’s easier for the layman to understand. If you don’t like any of these changes or want to change more, please feel more than welcome to edit it yourself. Thank you for your insightful question and I hope to see you around!
– DonielF
Aug 17 at 4:35
Welcome to Mi Yodeya! Please take a moment to look over our tour where you’ll find useful information about our site. I’ve gone ahead and helped you out with the tags and replaced the more yeshivish terminology you used with wording that’s easier for the layman to understand. If you don’t like any of these changes or want to change more, please feel more than welcome to edit it yourself. Thank you for your insightful question and I hope to see you around!
– DonielF
Aug 17 at 4:35
1
1
Does the same not apply to Pidyon Haben?
– Double AA♦
Aug 17 at 12:20
Does the same not apply to Pidyon Haben?
– Double AA♦
Aug 17 at 12:20
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
4
down vote
See Kessef Mishneh ad loc. who explains that this is a specific rule which applies to the first shearings (reishit hagez), derived from the word תתן used in Devarim 18:4.
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
4
down vote
See Kessef Mishneh ad loc. who explains that this is a specific rule which applies to the first shearings (reishit hagez), derived from the word תתן used in Devarim 18:4.
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
See Kessef Mishneh ad loc. who explains that this is a specific rule which applies to the first shearings (reishit hagez), derived from the word תתן used in Devarim 18:4.
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
up vote
4
down vote
See Kessef Mishneh ad loc. who explains that this is a specific rule which applies to the first shearings (reishit hagez), derived from the word תתן used in Devarim 18:4.
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
See Kessef Mishneh ad loc. who explains that this is a specific rule which applies to the first shearings (reishit hagez), derived from the word תתן used in Devarim 18:4.
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
answered Aug 17 at 6:09
Joel K
7,8281461
7,8281461
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Welcome to Mi Yodeya! Please take a moment to look over our tour where you’ll find useful information about our site. I’ve gone ahead and helped you out with the tags and replaced the more yeshivish terminology you used with wording that’s easier for the layman to understand. If you don’t like any of these changes or want to change more, please feel more than welcome to edit it yourself. Thank you for your insightful question and I hope to see you around!
– DonielF
Aug 17 at 4:35
1
Does the same not apply to Pidyon Haben?
– Double AA♦
Aug 17 at 12:20