How to translate ä¹ in classical Chinese texts?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
I know that ä¹ usually expresses doubt and is sometimes translated using rhetorical questions. But is it always true? I am wondering how should it be translated in such a case: "èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨". The full sentence is:
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
For the sake of clarity - the sentence is preceded with another one that contains the following statement: "ç¶ä½ÂæÂÂÃ¥ÂÂæ£ä¹Âæ®Â".
classical-chinese
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
I know that ä¹ usually expresses doubt and is sometimes translated using rhetorical questions. But is it always true? I am wondering how should it be translated in such a case: "èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨". The full sentence is:
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
For the sake of clarity - the sentence is preceded with another one that contains the following statement: "ç¶ä½ÂæÂÂÃ¥ÂÂæ£ä¹Âæ®Â".
classical-chinese
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
I know that ä¹ usually expresses doubt and is sometimes translated using rhetorical questions. But is it always true? I am wondering how should it be translated in such a case: "èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨". The full sentence is:
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
For the sake of clarity - the sentence is preceded with another one that contains the following statement: "ç¶ä½ÂæÂÂÃ¥ÂÂæ£ä¹Âæ®Â".
classical-chinese
I know that ä¹ usually expresses doubt and is sometimes translated using rhetorical questions. But is it always true? I am wondering how should it be translated in such a case: "èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨". The full sentence is:
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
For the sake of clarity - the sentence is preceded with another one that contains the following statement: "ç¶ä½ÂæÂÂÃ¥ÂÂæ£ä¹Âæ®Â".
classical-chinese
classical-chinese
asked Sep 25 at 11:08
McCzajnik
253
253
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
is it always true
no. only when ä¹ is at the end of a verse, then it might be interpreted as doubt, rhetorical question, or guess.
http://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/cgi-bin/cbdic/gsweb.cgi?ccd=hj97ow&o=e0&sec=sec1&op=v&view=0-1
in the verse
èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
"ä¹Â" means æ¼, a preposition (at, in, from, . . . etc).
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
i would suggest to interpret the verse as:
only the homo sapiens (æÂÂ人ä¹Â),
get (å¾Â) the upright (æ£) body (å½¢) & vital energy (æ°£),
therefore (æ¯以), its (å ¶) mind (å¿Â) is the most (æÂÂ) divine; (éÂÂ)
and (èÂÂ) depends on [such upright body and vital energy] (æÂÂ以), [homo sapiens ] succeed (éÂÂ) in (ä¹Â) the complete (å ¨) life (æ§å½)
have fun :)
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
ä¹ÂèÂÂ
ï¼ÂéÂÂå¯è¯Âæ°Âå©è¯Âä¹Âç¨ä¹Âï¼Â亦ä½Âä»Âè¯Âï¼ÂÃ¥ÂÂâÂÂäºÂâÂÂä¹Âä¹ÂãÂÂ
è¯ÂçÂÂï¼Â
é£Âä¹ÂèÂÂé©[å¨]
å«å£ä¹Âä¸Â西ï¼Âé³çªÂä¹ÂÃ¥ÂÂÃ¥ÂÂ[ä»Â]
å¾å°ÂçÂÂä¹Âæ¯[对]
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
is it always true
no. only when ä¹ is at the end of a verse, then it might be interpreted as doubt, rhetorical question, or guess.
http://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/cgi-bin/cbdic/gsweb.cgi?ccd=hj97ow&o=e0&sec=sec1&op=v&view=0-1
in the verse
èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
"ä¹Â" means æ¼, a preposition (at, in, from, . . . etc).
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
i would suggest to interpret the verse as:
only the homo sapiens (æÂÂ人ä¹Â),
get (å¾Â) the upright (æ£) body (å½¢) & vital energy (æ°£),
therefore (æ¯以), its (å ¶) mind (å¿Â) is the most (æÂÂ) divine; (éÂÂ)
and (èÂÂ) depends on [such upright body and vital energy] (æÂÂ以), [homo sapiens ] succeed (éÂÂ) in (ä¹Â) the complete (å ¨) life (æ§å½)
have fun :)
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
is it always true
no. only when ä¹ is at the end of a verse, then it might be interpreted as doubt, rhetorical question, or guess.
http://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/cgi-bin/cbdic/gsweb.cgi?ccd=hj97ow&o=e0&sec=sec1&op=v&view=0-1
in the verse
èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
"ä¹Â" means æ¼, a preposition (at, in, from, . . . etc).
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
i would suggest to interpret the verse as:
only the homo sapiens (æÂÂ人ä¹Â),
get (å¾Â) the upright (æ£) body (å½¢) & vital energy (æ°£),
therefore (æ¯以), its (å ¶) mind (å¿Â) is the most (æÂÂ) divine; (éÂÂ)
and (èÂÂ) depends on [such upright body and vital energy] (æÂÂ以), [homo sapiens ] succeed (éÂÂ) in (ä¹Â) the complete (å ¨) life (æ§å½)
have fun :)
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
is it always true
no. only when ä¹ is at the end of a verse, then it might be interpreted as doubt, rhetorical question, or guess.
http://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/cgi-bin/cbdic/gsweb.cgi?ccd=hj97ow&o=e0&sec=sec1&op=v&view=0-1
in the verse
èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
"ä¹Â" means æ¼, a preposition (at, in, from, . . . etc).
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
i would suggest to interpret the verse as:
only the homo sapiens (æÂÂ人ä¹Â),
get (å¾Â) the upright (æ£) body (å½¢) & vital energy (æ°£),
therefore (æ¯以), its (å ¶) mind (å¿Â) is the most (æÂÂ) divine; (éÂÂ)
and (èÂÂ) depends on [such upright body and vital energy] (æÂÂ以), [homo sapiens ] succeed (éÂÂ) in (ä¹Â) the complete (å ¨) life (æ§å½)
have fun :)
is it always true
no. only when ä¹ is at the end of a verse, then it might be interpreted as doubt, rhetorical question, or guess.
http://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/cgi-bin/cbdic/gsweb.cgi?ccd=hj97ow&o=e0&sec=sec1&op=v&view=0-1
in the verse
èÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
"ä¹Â" means æ¼, a preposition (at, in, from, . . . etc).
æÂÂ人ä¹Âï¼Âå¾Â堶形氣ä¹Âæ£ï¼Âæ¯以堶å¿ÂæÂÂéÂÂï¼ÂèÂÂæÂÂ以éÂÂä¹Âæ§å½ä¹Âå ¨
i would suggest to interpret the verse as:
only the homo sapiens (æÂÂ人ä¹Â),
get (å¾Â) the upright (æ£) body (å½¢) & vital energy (æ°£),
therefore (æ¯以), its (å ¶) mind (å¿Â) is the most (æÂÂ) divine; (éÂÂ)
and (èÂÂ) depends on [such upright body and vital energy] (æÂÂ以), [homo sapiens ] succeed (éÂÂ) in (ä¹Â) the complete (å ¨) life (æ§å½)
have fun :)
answered Sep 25 at 12:56
æ°´å··åÂÂè »
6,6221520
6,6221520
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
add a comment |Â
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
Thank you so much!
â McCzajnik
Sep 25 at 19:11
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
ä¹ÂèÂÂ
ï¼ÂéÂÂå¯è¯Âæ°Âå©è¯Âä¹Âç¨ä¹Âï¼Â亦ä½Âä»Âè¯Âï¼ÂÃ¥ÂÂâÂÂäºÂâÂÂä¹Âä¹ÂãÂÂ
è¯ÂçÂÂï¼Â
é£Âä¹ÂèÂÂé©[å¨]
å«å£ä¹Âä¸Â西ï¼Âé³çªÂä¹ÂÃ¥ÂÂÃ¥ÂÂ[ä»Â]
å¾å°ÂçÂÂä¹Âæ¯[对]
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
ä¹ÂèÂÂ
ï¼ÂéÂÂå¯è¯Âæ°Âå©è¯Âä¹Âç¨ä¹Âï¼Â亦ä½Âä»Âè¯Âï¼ÂÃ¥ÂÂâÂÂäºÂâÂÂä¹Âä¹ÂãÂÂ
è¯ÂçÂÂï¼Â
é£Âä¹ÂèÂÂé©[å¨]
å«å£ä¹Âä¸Â西ï¼Âé³çªÂä¹ÂÃ¥ÂÂÃ¥ÂÂ[ä»Â]
å¾å°ÂçÂÂä¹Âæ¯[对]
add a comment |Â
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
ä¹ÂèÂÂ
ï¼ÂéÂÂå¯è¯Âæ°Âå©è¯Âä¹Âç¨ä¹Âï¼Â亦ä½Âä»Âè¯Âï¼ÂÃ¥ÂÂâÂÂäºÂâÂÂä¹Âä¹ÂãÂÂ
è¯ÂçÂÂï¼Â
é£Âä¹ÂèÂÂé©[å¨]
å«å£ä¹Âä¸Â西ï¼Âé³çªÂä¹ÂÃ¥ÂÂÃ¥ÂÂ[ä»Â]
å¾å°ÂçÂÂä¹Âæ¯[对]
ä¹ÂèÂÂ
ï¼ÂéÂÂå¯è¯Âæ°Âå©è¯Âä¹Âç¨ä¹Âï¼Â亦ä½Âä»Âè¯Âï¼ÂÃ¥ÂÂâÂÂäºÂâÂÂä¹Âä¹ÂãÂÂ
è¯ÂçÂÂï¼Â
é£Âä¹ÂèÂÂé©[å¨]
å«å£ä¹Âä¸Â西ï¼Âé³çªÂä¹ÂÃ¥ÂÂÃ¥ÂÂ[ä»Â]
å¾å°ÂçÂÂä¹Âæ¯[对]
answered Sep 25 at 12:04
Toosky Hierot
43517
43517
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fchinese.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f31474%2fhow-to-translate-%25e4%25b9%258e-in-classical-chinese-texts%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password