What are the differences between “You gave upâ€, “You gave it up†and “You gave up on thatâ€?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
1
What are the differences between "And then you gave up", "And then you gave it up", "And then you gave up on that?"
phrase-usage
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
1
What are the differences between "And then you gave up", "And then you gave it up", "And then you gave up on that?"
phrase-usage
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
1
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
1
1
What are the differences between "And then you gave up", "And then you gave it up", "And then you gave up on that?"
phrase-usage
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
What are the differences between "And then you gave up", "And then you gave it up", "And then you gave up on that?"
phrase-usage
phrase-usage
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
asked Aug 11 at 5:04
brilliant
70921323
70921323
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
According to Cambridge Dictionary:
Give up: "to stop trying to do something before you have finished, usually because it is too difficult"
Give [something] up: "to stop doing a regular activity or job"
Give up on [something]: "to expect someone or something to fail"
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
1
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
 |Â
show 3 more comments
up vote
4
down vote
"Give it up" has two meanings that are different from "Give up" and "Give up on <something>":
- To wildly applaud. (A master of ceremonies will often ask an audience to "Give it up for <the next person to appear>.")
- To willingly have sex with someone. Using "give it up" with this meaning implies that the person who "gave it up" had sex earlier in the relationship than the speaker fully approves of, or in a less committed relationship than the speaker fully approves of.
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
add a comment |Â
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
According to Cambridge Dictionary:
Give up: "to stop trying to do something before you have finished, usually because it is too difficult"
Give [something] up: "to stop doing a regular activity or job"
Give up on [something]: "to expect someone or something to fail"
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
1
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
 |Â
show 3 more comments
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
According to Cambridge Dictionary:
Give up: "to stop trying to do something before you have finished, usually because it is too difficult"
Give [something] up: "to stop doing a regular activity or job"
Give up on [something]: "to expect someone or something to fail"
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
1
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
 |Â
show 3 more comments
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
According to Cambridge Dictionary:
Give up: "to stop trying to do something before you have finished, usually because it is too difficult"
Give [something] up: "to stop doing a regular activity or job"
Give up on [something]: "to expect someone or something to fail"
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
According to Cambridge Dictionary:
Give up: "to stop trying to do something before you have finished, usually because it is too difficult"
Give [something] up: "to stop doing a regular activity or job"
Give up on [something]: "to expect someone or something to fail"
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
answered Aug 11 at 6:01
nick012000
2835
2835
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
1
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
 |Â
show 3 more comments
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
1
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
"Give it up" can be a case of "give [something] up" if there's a clear antecedent for "it", but otherwise Jasper's answer is better for the "it" case.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:13
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Yeah, it's why I upvoted him. Though, with that said, neither of the meanings he listed are listed in that dictionary entry, and the meanings I listed are the three most closely related ones that illustrate the difference between them.
– nick012000
Aug 11 at 14:17
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
Meanings that aren't listed in the dictionary entry are probably the most important to get across to language learners.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:21
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
@R. -- This answer covers more phrases that the original poster asked about than my answer does, and cites a suitable dictionary. It probably provides a definition for a larger fraction of uses of "give it up" than my answer does. I upvoted it.
– Jasper
Aug 11 at 15:39
1
1
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
@brilliant: The sense in which I'm using antecedent is the grammatical one: antecedent of a pronoun, the prior noun to which it refers. For example, in "He really loved smoking, but decided to give it up", it's clear that "it" refers to "smoking" and the sense of "give it up" is the "give [something] up" in this answer.
– R..
Aug 11 at 17:01
 |Â
show 3 more comments
up vote
4
down vote
"Give it up" has two meanings that are different from "Give up" and "Give up on <something>":
- To wildly applaud. (A master of ceremonies will often ask an audience to "Give it up for <the next person to appear>.")
- To willingly have sex with someone. Using "give it up" with this meaning implies that the person who "gave it up" had sex earlier in the relationship than the speaker fully approves of, or in a less committed relationship than the speaker fully approves of.
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
"Give it up" has two meanings that are different from "Give up" and "Give up on <something>":
- To wildly applaud. (A master of ceremonies will often ask an audience to "Give it up for <the next person to appear>.")
- To willingly have sex with someone. Using "give it up" with this meaning implies that the person who "gave it up" had sex earlier in the relationship than the speaker fully approves of, or in a less committed relationship than the speaker fully approves of.
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
up vote
4
down vote
"Give it up" has two meanings that are different from "Give up" and "Give up on <something>":
- To wildly applaud. (A master of ceremonies will often ask an audience to "Give it up for <the next person to appear>.")
- To willingly have sex with someone. Using "give it up" with this meaning implies that the person who "gave it up" had sex earlier in the relationship than the speaker fully approves of, or in a less committed relationship than the speaker fully approves of.
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
"Give it up" has two meanings that are different from "Give up" and "Give up on <something>":
- To wildly applaud. (A master of ceremonies will often ask an audience to "Give it up for <the next person to appear>.")
- To willingly have sex with someone. Using "give it up" with this meaning implies that the person who "gave it up" had sex earlier in the relationship than the speaker fully approves of, or in a less committed relationship than the speaker fully approves of.
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
edited Aug 11 at 15:40
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
answered Aug 11 at 9:00
Jasper
16.8k43264
16.8k43264
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
add a comment |Â
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
WOW! Thanks for this input!
– brilliant
Aug 11 at 9:41
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
I would say "at least two meanings"; there are likely more. But this kind of answer is really helpful in an ELL context.
– R..
Aug 11 at 14:16
add a comment |Â
Â
draft saved
draft discarded
Â
draft saved
draft discarded
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f175830%2fwhat-are-the-differences-between-you-gave-up-you-gave-it-up-and-you-gave-u%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password