A perfectly fitting pot and its lid often stick after cooking
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
I encountered a question that asks for the reason that a perfectly fitting pot and its lid often stick after cooking when it cools down. The answer in the solution manual was that the pressure decreases when the temperature decreases. I understand that point, but my problem is the following: The pot before being heated during cooking is influenced only by the atmospheric value, and the food inside that pot is the atmospheric pressure also. So this is the initial state for the pressure inside the pot now. When heated the pressure inside the pot increases. When we let the pot cool down to the room tempreture, would the pressure return to its initial value which is the atmospheric pressure? Why does the solution manual consider a vacuum inside the pot?
thermodynamics pressure
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
I encountered a question that asks for the reason that a perfectly fitting pot and its lid often stick after cooking when it cools down. The answer in the solution manual was that the pressure decreases when the temperature decreases. I understand that point, but my problem is the following: The pot before being heated during cooking is influenced only by the atmospheric value, and the food inside that pot is the atmospheric pressure also. So this is the initial state for the pressure inside the pot now. When heated the pressure inside the pot increases. When we let the pot cool down to the room tempreture, would the pressure return to its initial value which is the atmospheric pressure? Why does the solution manual consider a vacuum inside the pot?
thermodynamics pressure
New contributor
To see it in reverse, take a mason jar with one of those rubber seals, put room temperature water in it, close the jar, and place it in the fridge. Leave it for at least 30 minutes, and then take it out and try to open it - the rubber seal will be very snug to the jar!
– N. Steinle
6 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
I encountered a question that asks for the reason that a perfectly fitting pot and its lid often stick after cooking when it cools down. The answer in the solution manual was that the pressure decreases when the temperature decreases. I understand that point, but my problem is the following: The pot before being heated during cooking is influenced only by the atmospheric value, and the food inside that pot is the atmospheric pressure also. So this is the initial state for the pressure inside the pot now. When heated the pressure inside the pot increases. When we let the pot cool down to the room tempreture, would the pressure return to its initial value which is the atmospheric pressure? Why does the solution manual consider a vacuum inside the pot?
thermodynamics pressure
New contributor
I encountered a question that asks for the reason that a perfectly fitting pot and its lid often stick after cooking when it cools down. The answer in the solution manual was that the pressure decreases when the temperature decreases. I understand that point, but my problem is the following: The pot before being heated during cooking is influenced only by the atmospheric value, and the food inside that pot is the atmospheric pressure also. So this is the initial state for the pressure inside the pot now. When heated the pressure inside the pot increases. When we let the pot cool down to the room tempreture, would the pressure return to its initial value which is the atmospheric pressure? Why does the solution manual consider a vacuum inside the pot?
thermodynamics pressure
thermodynamics pressure
New contributor
New contributor
edited 7 hours ago
Aaron Stevens
6,5122934
6,5122934
New contributor
asked 7 hours ago
A.ELAK
182
182
New contributor
New contributor
To see it in reverse, take a mason jar with one of those rubber seals, put room temperature water in it, close the jar, and place it in the fridge. Leave it for at least 30 minutes, and then take it out and try to open it - the rubber seal will be very snug to the jar!
– N. Steinle
6 hours ago
add a comment |
To see it in reverse, take a mason jar with one of those rubber seals, put room temperature water in it, close the jar, and place it in the fridge. Leave it for at least 30 minutes, and then take it out and try to open it - the rubber seal will be very snug to the jar!
– N. Steinle
6 hours ago
To see it in reverse, take a mason jar with one of those rubber seals, put room temperature water in it, close the jar, and place it in the fridge. Leave it for at least 30 minutes, and then take it out and try to open it - the rubber seal will be very snug to the jar!
– N. Steinle
6 hours ago
To see it in reverse, take a mason jar with one of those rubber seals, put room temperature water in it, close the jar, and place it in the fridge. Leave it for at least 30 minutes, and then take it out and try to open it - the rubber seal will be very snug to the jar!
– N. Steinle
6 hours ago
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
As @Stephen C. Steel pointed out, the pressure increase in the pot (due to heating the air in the pot) relative to the outside pressure exerts a net force on the lid causing it to vent. However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat. The important thing is to understand the mechanism involved for the lid sticking on cool down.
Let’s assume the cooking starts with the lid off. Generally you will have some steam (water vapor) developed in the pot. The lid is put on just before turning off the heat. Inside the pot we have a mixture of air and water vapor, likely near saturation, which is nearly equal to the outside pressure, 1 atm. But the pressure inside the pot is the sum of the partial pressures of the water vapor and dry air. As the mixture cools the water vapors condenses into a liquid. The pressure in the pot is now less due to the loss of the partial pressure of the water vapor. The lower pressure in the pot versus the pressure outside the pot causes a force holding down the lid, if it consists of a relatively good seal.
I should add the fact that in addition to the drop in pressure due to condensation, the drop in temperature of the dry air in essentially a fixed volume also results in a pressure drop. Considering air as an ideal gas, from the ideal gas law:
$$frac P_1V_1T_!=frac P_2V_2T_2$$
And for $V=$constant
$$frac P_1T_!=frac P_2T_2$$
Since $T_2<T_1$, then $P_2<P_1$
Hope this helps
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
You've made the wrong assumption about what a perfectly fitting lid does. Rather than sealing perfectly, it will vent gas when the interior is at a higher pressure (the lid will lift), but seal when the exterior pressure is higher (the lid is pressed down).
New contributor
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
As @Stephen C. Steel pointed out, the pressure increase in the pot (due to heating the air in the pot) relative to the outside pressure exerts a net force on the lid causing it to vent. However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat. The important thing is to understand the mechanism involved for the lid sticking on cool down.
Let’s assume the cooking starts with the lid off. Generally you will have some steam (water vapor) developed in the pot. The lid is put on just before turning off the heat. Inside the pot we have a mixture of air and water vapor, likely near saturation, which is nearly equal to the outside pressure, 1 atm. But the pressure inside the pot is the sum of the partial pressures of the water vapor and dry air. As the mixture cools the water vapors condenses into a liquid. The pressure in the pot is now less due to the loss of the partial pressure of the water vapor. The lower pressure in the pot versus the pressure outside the pot causes a force holding down the lid, if it consists of a relatively good seal.
I should add the fact that in addition to the drop in pressure due to condensation, the drop in temperature of the dry air in essentially a fixed volume also results in a pressure drop. Considering air as an ideal gas, from the ideal gas law:
$$frac P_1V_1T_!=frac P_2V_2T_2$$
And for $V=$constant
$$frac P_1T_!=frac P_2T_2$$
Since $T_2<T_1$, then $P_2<P_1$
Hope this helps
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
As @Stephen C. Steel pointed out, the pressure increase in the pot (due to heating the air in the pot) relative to the outside pressure exerts a net force on the lid causing it to vent. However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat. The important thing is to understand the mechanism involved for the lid sticking on cool down.
Let’s assume the cooking starts with the lid off. Generally you will have some steam (water vapor) developed in the pot. The lid is put on just before turning off the heat. Inside the pot we have a mixture of air and water vapor, likely near saturation, which is nearly equal to the outside pressure, 1 atm. But the pressure inside the pot is the sum of the partial pressures of the water vapor and dry air. As the mixture cools the water vapors condenses into a liquid. The pressure in the pot is now less due to the loss of the partial pressure of the water vapor. The lower pressure in the pot versus the pressure outside the pot causes a force holding down the lid, if it consists of a relatively good seal.
I should add the fact that in addition to the drop in pressure due to condensation, the drop in temperature of the dry air in essentially a fixed volume also results in a pressure drop. Considering air as an ideal gas, from the ideal gas law:
$$frac P_1V_1T_!=frac P_2V_2T_2$$
And for $V=$constant
$$frac P_1T_!=frac P_2T_2$$
Since $T_2<T_1$, then $P_2<P_1$
Hope this helps
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
As @Stephen C. Steel pointed out, the pressure increase in the pot (due to heating the air in the pot) relative to the outside pressure exerts a net force on the lid causing it to vent. However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat. The important thing is to understand the mechanism involved for the lid sticking on cool down.
Let’s assume the cooking starts with the lid off. Generally you will have some steam (water vapor) developed in the pot. The lid is put on just before turning off the heat. Inside the pot we have a mixture of air and water vapor, likely near saturation, which is nearly equal to the outside pressure, 1 atm. But the pressure inside the pot is the sum of the partial pressures of the water vapor and dry air. As the mixture cools the water vapors condenses into a liquid. The pressure in the pot is now less due to the loss of the partial pressure of the water vapor. The lower pressure in the pot versus the pressure outside the pot causes a force holding down the lid, if it consists of a relatively good seal.
I should add the fact that in addition to the drop in pressure due to condensation, the drop in temperature of the dry air in essentially a fixed volume also results in a pressure drop. Considering air as an ideal gas, from the ideal gas law:
$$frac P_1V_1T_!=frac P_2V_2T_2$$
And for $V=$constant
$$frac P_1T_!=frac P_2T_2$$
Since $T_2<T_1$, then $P_2<P_1$
Hope this helps
As @Stephen C. Steel pointed out, the pressure increase in the pot (due to heating the air in the pot) relative to the outside pressure exerts a net force on the lid causing it to vent. However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat. The important thing is to understand the mechanism involved for the lid sticking on cool down.
Let’s assume the cooking starts with the lid off. Generally you will have some steam (water vapor) developed in the pot. The lid is put on just before turning off the heat. Inside the pot we have a mixture of air and water vapor, likely near saturation, which is nearly equal to the outside pressure, 1 atm. But the pressure inside the pot is the sum of the partial pressures of the water vapor and dry air. As the mixture cools the water vapors condenses into a liquid. The pressure in the pot is now less due to the loss of the partial pressure of the water vapor. The lower pressure in the pot versus the pressure outside the pot causes a force holding down the lid, if it consists of a relatively good seal.
I should add the fact that in addition to the drop in pressure due to condensation, the drop in temperature of the dry air in essentially a fixed volume also results in a pressure drop. Considering air as an ideal gas, from the ideal gas law:
$$frac P_1V_1T_!=frac P_2V_2T_2$$
And for $V=$constant
$$frac P_1T_!=frac P_2T_2$$
Since $T_2<T_1$, then $P_2<P_1$
Hope this helps
edited 5 hours ago
answered 6 hours ago
Bob D
1,434211
1,434211
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
add a comment |
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
Thanks for your answer . But there is a point here is the force difference between the outside and the inside pressure leads to the act of sticking where is the normal force that the pot produces on the lid If there is a Free body diagram on the lid of the pot it will have the forces from the pressure and the force provided from the pot on the lid why this normal force do not cancel the force result from the difference in pressures
– A.ELAK
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
RE: "However, it doesn’t matter if the lid is on before the cooking process starts, or put on just before turning off the heat." // That isn't true. The assumption is that the lid acts as a one way valve. It lets excess pressure out, but does not leak air in. Thus if the pot starts with the lid on, then some gas would escape as vapor pressure of water increases. This would sweep out some air. So if the pot had been boiling for some time all the air would be displaced and only water vapor would remain in the head space.
– MaxW
3 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@MaxW Sure it can act as a one way valve. All I'm saying is you don't have to start with the lid on to get the sticking effect..
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
@A.ELAK The weight of the lid is the minimum force necessary to remove the lid, whether or not your cooking with the pot. The cooling effect after cooking only adds to the force necessary to remove the lid due to the pressure drop inside. I don't see how the weight of the lid cancels out the effect of the pressure drop. Maybe I'm not understanding your comment.
– Bob D
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
You've made the wrong assumption about what a perfectly fitting lid does. Rather than sealing perfectly, it will vent gas when the interior is at a higher pressure (the lid will lift), but seal when the exterior pressure is higher (the lid is pressed down).
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
You've made the wrong assumption about what a perfectly fitting lid does. Rather than sealing perfectly, it will vent gas when the interior is at a higher pressure (the lid will lift), but seal when the exterior pressure is higher (the lid is pressed down).
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
up vote
7
down vote
You've made the wrong assumption about what a perfectly fitting lid does. Rather than sealing perfectly, it will vent gas when the interior is at a higher pressure (the lid will lift), but seal when the exterior pressure is higher (the lid is pressed down).
New contributor
You've made the wrong assumption about what a perfectly fitting lid does. Rather than sealing perfectly, it will vent gas when the interior is at a higher pressure (the lid will lift), but seal when the exterior pressure is higher (the lid is pressed down).
New contributor
New contributor
answered 6 hours ago
Stephen C. Steel
1711
1711
New contributor
New contributor
add a comment |
add a comment |
A.ELAK is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
A.ELAK is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
A.ELAK is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
A.ELAK is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphysics.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f440322%2fa-perfectly-fitting-pot-and-its-lid-often-stick-after-cooking%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
To see it in reverse, take a mason jar with one of those rubber seals, put room temperature water in it, close the jar, and place it in the fridge. Leave it for at least 30 minutes, and then take it out and try to open it - the rubber seal will be very snug to the jar!
– N. Steinle
6 hours ago