Canning with candles
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
I am not sure about the right terminology as I am not a native speaker, but is it possible to conserve solid food in a jar with a candle?
Boiling is used to decrease air and for the food to be well conserved it must not have much oxygen. The food is suffocating. A tea candle placed inside will suck the air too and will extinguish when there is no sufficient air inside.
food-preservation boiling canning
add a comment |
I am not sure about the right terminology as I am not a native speaker, but is it possible to conserve solid food in a jar with a candle?
Boiling is used to decrease air and for the food to be well conserved it must not have much oxygen. The food is suffocating. A tea candle placed inside will suck the air too and will extinguish when there is no sufficient air inside.
food-preservation boiling canning
11
The main purpose of boiling when canning isn't removal of air. It's done to kill microbes and their spores.
– Deolater
Feb 12 at 14:31
2
@MatthewRead Boiling in a pot releases water vapor, not steam. Heating the air causes it to expand significantly, reducing the amount of air molecules in the jar. By sealing it before it cools, you can create a partial vacuum in the jar which helps to preserve food (but not from anaerobic microbes.)
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 18:32
2
Paraffin wax used to be commonly used as a cover for jams and jellies. It kept the food anaerobic without having to go through the whole rigamarole. That said, I would not trust what is used for wax in modern candles. Some are quite the miracles of chemistry, and decidedly not food grade. You can still buy paraffin in most canning aisles.
– Wayfaring Stranger
Feb 13 at 0:15
add a comment |
I am not sure about the right terminology as I am not a native speaker, but is it possible to conserve solid food in a jar with a candle?
Boiling is used to decrease air and for the food to be well conserved it must not have much oxygen. The food is suffocating. A tea candle placed inside will suck the air too and will extinguish when there is no sufficient air inside.
food-preservation boiling canning
I am not sure about the right terminology as I am not a native speaker, but is it possible to conserve solid food in a jar with a candle?
Boiling is used to decrease air and for the food to be well conserved it must not have much oxygen. The food is suffocating. A tea candle placed inside will suck the air too and will extinguish when there is no sufficient air inside.
food-preservation boiling canning
food-preservation boiling canning
asked Feb 12 at 9:51
CorelationCorelation
3614
3614
11
The main purpose of boiling when canning isn't removal of air. It's done to kill microbes and their spores.
– Deolater
Feb 12 at 14:31
2
@MatthewRead Boiling in a pot releases water vapor, not steam. Heating the air causes it to expand significantly, reducing the amount of air molecules in the jar. By sealing it before it cools, you can create a partial vacuum in the jar which helps to preserve food (but not from anaerobic microbes.)
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 18:32
2
Paraffin wax used to be commonly used as a cover for jams and jellies. It kept the food anaerobic without having to go through the whole rigamarole. That said, I would not trust what is used for wax in modern candles. Some are quite the miracles of chemistry, and decidedly not food grade. You can still buy paraffin in most canning aisles.
– Wayfaring Stranger
Feb 13 at 0:15
add a comment |
11
The main purpose of boiling when canning isn't removal of air. It's done to kill microbes and their spores.
– Deolater
Feb 12 at 14:31
2
@MatthewRead Boiling in a pot releases water vapor, not steam. Heating the air causes it to expand significantly, reducing the amount of air molecules in the jar. By sealing it before it cools, you can create a partial vacuum in the jar which helps to preserve food (but not from anaerobic microbes.)
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 18:32
2
Paraffin wax used to be commonly used as a cover for jams and jellies. It kept the food anaerobic without having to go through the whole rigamarole. That said, I would not trust what is used for wax in modern candles. Some are quite the miracles of chemistry, and decidedly not food grade. You can still buy paraffin in most canning aisles.
– Wayfaring Stranger
Feb 13 at 0:15
11
11
The main purpose of boiling when canning isn't removal of air. It's done to kill microbes and their spores.
– Deolater
Feb 12 at 14:31
The main purpose of boiling when canning isn't removal of air. It's done to kill microbes and their spores.
– Deolater
Feb 12 at 14:31
2
2
@MatthewRead Boiling in a pot releases water vapor, not steam. Heating the air causes it to expand significantly, reducing the amount of air molecules in the jar. By sealing it before it cools, you can create a partial vacuum in the jar which helps to preserve food (but not from anaerobic microbes.)
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 18:32
@MatthewRead Boiling in a pot releases water vapor, not steam. Heating the air causes it to expand significantly, reducing the amount of air molecules in the jar. By sealing it before it cools, you can create a partial vacuum in the jar which helps to preserve food (but not from anaerobic microbes.)
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 18:32
2
2
Paraffin wax used to be commonly used as a cover for jams and jellies. It kept the food anaerobic without having to go through the whole rigamarole. That said, I would not trust what is used for wax in modern candles. Some are quite the miracles of chemistry, and decidedly not food grade. You can still buy paraffin in most canning aisles.
– Wayfaring Stranger
Feb 13 at 0:15
Paraffin wax used to be commonly used as a cover for jams and jellies. It kept the food anaerobic without having to go through the whole rigamarole. That said, I would not trust what is used for wax in modern candles. Some are quite the miracles of chemistry, and decidedly not food grade. You can still buy paraffin in most canning aisles.
– Wayfaring Stranger
Feb 13 at 0:15
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
The short answer is: No.
The more elaborate answer is that certain bacteria are anaerobic and food needs to be heat treated to ensure it can be safely stored. Especial mention: Clostridium botulinum which leaves deadly toxins.
The tealight inside the jar will not produce the heat needed for pasteurization.
12
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
4
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
11
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
4
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
2
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
|
show 4 more comments
I can't add a comment but would like to point out that I have seen melted paraffin used to create a sort of seal on the top of a jam/jelly preserve.
That doesn't prevent spoilage by mold or bacteria but it does keep a skin from developing or oxidation of the surface layer. Since paraffin shrinks a fair bit as it cools, this approach does have limits.
add a comment |
It comes down to how hot you can get the can get the jar with a candle.
If your food contains water, then it will only heat above 100° C if it is under pressure, which means you'll need to seal the jar. Maybe, the jar is strong enough that its internal temperature could reach 120° C. If so, then maintaining that temperature for a while would kill all the microbes, and the food would be preserved.
On the other hand, maybe the pressure inside the jar would cause it to explode before the desired temperature was reached.
On the other other hand, maybe the jar would radiate heat too quickly--and absorb heat from the candle too slowly--so that it would never reach 120° C. You might be able to work around this by building some kind of reflective insulating enclosure for the jar, but it would be difficult to properly insulate it without also cutting off the air to the candle.
So the answer is maybe but I wouldn't recommend it.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "49"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcooking.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f96311%2fcanning-with-candles%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The short answer is: No.
The more elaborate answer is that certain bacteria are anaerobic and food needs to be heat treated to ensure it can be safely stored. Especial mention: Clostridium botulinum which leaves deadly toxins.
The tealight inside the jar will not produce the heat needed for pasteurization.
12
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
4
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
11
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
4
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
2
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
|
show 4 more comments
The short answer is: No.
The more elaborate answer is that certain bacteria are anaerobic and food needs to be heat treated to ensure it can be safely stored. Especial mention: Clostridium botulinum which leaves deadly toxins.
The tealight inside the jar will not produce the heat needed for pasteurization.
12
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
4
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
11
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
4
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
2
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
|
show 4 more comments
The short answer is: No.
The more elaborate answer is that certain bacteria are anaerobic and food needs to be heat treated to ensure it can be safely stored. Especial mention: Clostridium botulinum which leaves deadly toxins.
The tealight inside the jar will not produce the heat needed for pasteurization.
The short answer is: No.
The more elaborate answer is that certain bacteria are anaerobic and food needs to be heat treated to ensure it can be safely stored. Especial mention: Clostridium botulinum which leaves deadly toxins.
The tealight inside the jar will not produce the heat needed for pasteurization.
answered Feb 12 at 10:20
BaffledCookBaffledCook
10.2k1771125
10.2k1771125
12
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
4
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
11
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
4
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
2
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
|
show 4 more comments
12
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
4
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
11
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
4
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
2
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
12
12
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
That's aside from the fact the food will smell of burned candle-wax ;)
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:28
4
4
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
@Tetsujin Well ... I dunno, maybe paraffin is an acquired taste? :-)
– BaffledCook
Feb 12 at 10:36
11
11
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
For that authentic "70's restaurant with dribbly candlestick wine bottles on the table" vibe.
– Tetsujin
Feb 12 at 10:38
4
4
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
Just a note, to kill botulin spores, you must get the food above normal boiling temperature using a pressure cooker.
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 16:58
2
2
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
@JimmyJames This is technically true, but boiling water canning is only used to destroy harmful microbes in items which are acidic, salty, or sugary enough to prevent the growth of most other microbes, including botulin spores (though you should still be cautious of feeding these to very young children or the immuno-suppressed). Pressure canning is a more sure way to destroy more hardy microbes and can thus be used to preserve less acidic items.
– BloodGain
Feb 13 at 0:28
|
show 4 more comments
I can't add a comment but would like to point out that I have seen melted paraffin used to create a sort of seal on the top of a jam/jelly preserve.
That doesn't prevent spoilage by mold or bacteria but it does keep a skin from developing or oxidation of the surface layer. Since paraffin shrinks a fair bit as it cools, this approach does have limits.
add a comment |
I can't add a comment but would like to point out that I have seen melted paraffin used to create a sort of seal on the top of a jam/jelly preserve.
That doesn't prevent spoilage by mold or bacteria but it does keep a skin from developing or oxidation of the surface layer. Since paraffin shrinks a fair bit as it cools, this approach does have limits.
add a comment |
I can't add a comment but would like to point out that I have seen melted paraffin used to create a sort of seal on the top of a jam/jelly preserve.
That doesn't prevent spoilage by mold or bacteria but it does keep a skin from developing or oxidation of the surface layer. Since paraffin shrinks a fair bit as it cools, this approach does have limits.
I can't add a comment but would like to point out that I have seen melted paraffin used to create a sort of seal on the top of a jam/jelly preserve.
That doesn't prevent spoilage by mold or bacteria but it does keep a skin from developing or oxidation of the surface layer. Since paraffin shrinks a fair bit as it cools, this approach does have limits.
answered Feb 13 at 18:53
C TeegardenC Teegarden
211
211
add a comment |
add a comment |
It comes down to how hot you can get the can get the jar with a candle.
If your food contains water, then it will only heat above 100° C if it is under pressure, which means you'll need to seal the jar. Maybe, the jar is strong enough that its internal temperature could reach 120° C. If so, then maintaining that temperature for a while would kill all the microbes, and the food would be preserved.
On the other hand, maybe the pressure inside the jar would cause it to explode before the desired temperature was reached.
On the other other hand, maybe the jar would radiate heat too quickly--and absorb heat from the candle too slowly--so that it would never reach 120° C. You might be able to work around this by building some kind of reflective insulating enclosure for the jar, but it would be difficult to properly insulate it without also cutting off the air to the candle.
So the answer is maybe but I wouldn't recommend it.
add a comment |
It comes down to how hot you can get the can get the jar with a candle.
If your food contains water, then it will only heat above 100° C if it is under pressure, which means you'll need to seal the jar. Maybe, the jar is strong enough that its internal temperature could reach 120° C. If so, then maintaining that temperature for a while would kill all the microbes, and the food would be preserved.
On the other hand, maybe the pressure inside the jar would cause it to explode before the desired temperature was reached.
On the other other hand, maybe the jar would radiate heat too quickly--and absorb heat from the candle too slowly--so that it would never reach 120° C. You might be able to work around this by building some kind of reflective insulating enclosure for the jar, but it would be difficult to properly insulate it without also cutting off the air to the candle.
So the answer is maybe but I wouldn't recommend it.
add a comment |
It comes down to how hot you can get the can get the jar with a candle.
If your food contains water, then it will only heat above 100° C if it is under pressure, which means you'll need to seal the jar. Maybe, the jar is strong enough that its internal temperature could reach 120° C. If so, then maintaining that temperature for a while would kill all the microbes, and the food would be preserved.
On the other hand, maybe the pressure inside the jar would cause it to explode before the desired temperature was reached.
On the other other hand, maybe the jar would radiate heat too quickly--and absorb heat from the candle too slowly--so that it would never reach 120° C. You might be able to work around this by building some kind of reflective insulating enclosure for the jar, but it would be difficult to properly insulate it without also cutting off the air to the candle.
So the answer is maybe but I wouldn't recommend it.
It comes down to how hot you can get the can get the jar with a candle.
If your food contains water, then it will only heat above 100° C if it is under pressure, which means you'll need to seal the jar. Maybe, the jar is strong enough that its internal temperature could reach 120° C. If so, then maintaining that temperature for a while would kill all the microbes, and the food would be preserved.
On the other hand, maybe the pressure inside the jar would cause it to explode before the desired temperature was reached.
On the other other hand, maybe the jar would radiate heat too quickly--and absorb heat from the candle too slowly--so that it would never reach 120° C. You might be able to work around this by building some kind of reflective insulating enclosure for the jar, but it would be difficult to properly insulate it without also cutting off the air to the candle.
So the answer is maybe but I wouldn't recommend it.
answered Feb 12 at 18:53
MatrixManAtYrServiceMatrixManAtYrService
1131
1131
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Seasoned Advice!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcooking.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f96311%2fcanning-with-candles%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
11
The main purpose of boiling when canning isn't removal of air. It's done to kill microbes and their spores.
– Deolater
Feb 12 at 14:31
2
@MatthewRead Boiling in a pot releases water vapor, not steam. Heating the air causes it to expand significantly, reducing the amount of air molecules in the jar. By sealing it before it cools, you can create a partial vacuum in the jar which helps to preserve food (but not from anaerobic microbes.)
– JimmyJames
Feb 12 at 18:32
2
Paraffin wax used to be commonly used as a cover for jams and jellies. It kept the food anaerobic without having to go through the whole rigamarole. That said, I would not trust what is used for wax in modern candles. Some are quite the miracles of chemistry, and decidedly not food grade. You can still buy paraffin in most canning aisles.
– Wayfaring Stranger
Feb 13 at 0:15