Bayes version for continuous case, what does the integral mean?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
In bayes version for continuous case, what does it mean to integrate with respect to $dtheta$ when $theta$ is a vector not a a scalar value?
$$p(theta|D) = fracp(Dp(D)$$
Where $D$ is a set of observed data points, and $theta$ is a vector of parameters to be estimated.
$$ p(D) = int p(D|theta)p(theta)dtheta $$
Is this integral a surface integral, component-wise integral or what ?
bayesian integral
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
In bayes version for continuous case, what does it mean to integrate with respect to $dtheta$ when $theta$ is a vector not a a scalar value?
$$p(theta|D) = fracp(Dp(D)$$
Where $D$ is a set of observed data points, and $theta$ is a vector of parameters to be estimated.
$$ p(D) = int p(D|theta)p(theta)dtheta $$
Is this integral a surface integral, component-wise integral or what ?
bayesian integral
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
You are computing the marginal distribution of $p(D)$ over the range of your parameter space $theta in Theta$. The choice of integral depends on how your parameter space is defined.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 16:48
Can you give an example with a specific parameter space? I'm not sure I fully understand your answer
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 17:27
2
Say your parameter $theta$ is a 2-D vector and bounded, i.e., $theta_1 in [a_1, b_1]$ and $theta_2 in [a_2, b_2]$, then $Theta in [a_1, b_1] times [a_2, b_2] $, which is a surface.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 18:01
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
In bayes version for continuous case, what does it mean to integrate with respect to $dtheta$ when $theta$ is a vector not a a scalar value?
$$p(theta|D) = fracp(Dp(D)$$
Where $D$ is a set of observed data points, and $theta$ is a vector of parameters to be estimated.
$$ p(D) = int p(D|theta)p(theta)dtheta $$
Is this integral a surface integral, component-wise integral or what ?
bayesian integral
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
In bayes version for continuous case, what does it mean to integrate with respect to $dtheta$ when $theta$ is a vector not a a scalar value?
$$p(theta|D) = fracp(Dp(D)$$
Where $D$ is a set of observed data points, and $theta$ is a vector of parameters to be estimated.
$$ p(D) = int p(D|theta)p(theta)dtheta $$
Is this integral a surface integral, component-wise integral or what ?
bayesian integral
bayesian integral
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
asked Sep 22 at 16:42
Loai Ghoraba
1063
1063
You are computing the marginal distribution of $p(D)$ over the range of your parameter space $theta in Theta$. The choice of integral depends on how your parameter space is defined.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 16:48
Can you give an example with a specific parameter space? I'm not sure I fully understand your answer
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 17:27
2
Say your parameter $theta$ is a 2-D vector and bounded, i.e., $theta_1 in [a_1, b_1]$ and $theta_2 in [a_2, b_2]$, then $Theta in [a_1, b_1] times [a_2, b_2] $, which is a surface.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 18:01
add a comment |Â
You are computing the marginal distribution of $p(D)$ over the range of your parameter space $theta in Theta$. The choice of integral depends on how your parameter space is defined.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 16:48
Can you give an example with a specific parameter space? I'm not sure I fully understand your answer
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 17:27
2
Say your parameter $theta$ is a 2-D vector and bounded, i.e., $theta_1 in [a_1, b_1]$ and $theta_2 in [a_2, b_2]$, then $Theta in [a_1, b_1] times [a_2, b_2] $, which is a surface.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 18:01
You are computing the marginal distribution of $p(D)$ over the range of your parameter space $theta in Theta$. The choice of integral depends on how your parameter space is defined.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 16:48
You are computing the marginal distribution of $p(D)$ over the range of your parameter space $theta in Theta$. The choice of integral depends on how your parameter space is defined.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 16:48
Can you give an example with a specific parameter space? I'm not sure I fully understand your answer
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 17:27
Can you give an example with a specific parameter space? I'm not sure I fully understand your answer
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 17:27
2
2
Say your parameter $theta$ is a 2-D vector and bounded, i.e., $theta_1 in [a_1, b_1]$ and $theta_2 in [a_2, b_2]$, then $Theta in [a_1, b_1] times [a_2, b_2] $, which is a surface.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 18:01
Say your parameter $theta$ is a 2-D vector and bounded, i.e., $theta_1 in [a_1, b_1]$ and $theta_2 in [a_2, b_2]$, then $Theta in [a_1, b_1] times [a_2, b_2] $, which is a surface.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 18:01
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
That will be the n-dimensional integral, like the 2D case below: $$p(D) = int_Thetaint p(D | theta_1,theta_2)p(theta_1,theta_2)dtheta_1dtheta_2$$
Because it does not matter if you put them in a vector or not; if you formulate your likelihood and joint PDF correctly. You just have $n$ random variables.
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
add a comment |Â
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
That will be the n-dimensional integral, like the 2D case below: $$p(D) = int_Thetaint p(D | theta_1,theta_2)p(theta_1,theta_2)dtheta_1dtheta_2$$
Because it does not matter if you put them in a vector or not; if you formulate your likelihood and joint PDF correctly. You just have $n$ random variables.
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
That will be the n-dimensional integral, like the 2D case below: $$p(D) = int_Thetaint p(D | theta_1,theta_2)p(theta_1,theta_2)dtheta_1dtheta_2$$
Because it does not matter if you put them in a vector or not; if you formulate your likelihood and joint PDF correctly. You just have $n$ random variables.
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
add a comment |Â
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
up vote
3
down vote
accepted
That will be the n-dimensional integral, like the 2D case below: $$p(D) = int_Thetaint p(D | theta_1,theta_2)p(theta_1,theta_2)dtheta_1dtheta_2$$
Because it does not matter if you put them in a vector or not; if you formulate your likelihood and joint PDF correctly. You just have $n$ random variables.
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
That will be the n-dimensional integral, like the 2D case below: $$p(D) = int_Thetaint p(D | theta_1,theta_2)p(theta_1,theta_2)dtheta_1dtheta_2$$
Because it does not matter if you put them in a vector or not; if you formulate your likelihood and joint PDF correctly. You just have $n$ random variables.
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
answered Sep 22 at 16:51
gunes
1,1308
1,1308
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
add a comment |Â
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Just to make sure, so it is not a surface integral, right? That is , $dtheta$ is just a compact representation of multiple deltas multiplied together ?
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 21:03
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
Well, what would you call integrals with $dxdy$?
– gunes
Sep 22 at 21:12
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
You are right, my bad :)
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 23 at 17:45
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstats.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f368200%2fbayes-version-for-continuous-case-what-does-the-integral-mean%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
You are computing the marginal distribution of $p(D)$ over the range of your parameter space $theta in Theta$. The choice of integral depends on how your parameter space is defined.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 16:48
Can you give an example with a specific parameter space? I'm not sure I fully understand your answer
– Loai Ghoraba
Sep 22 at 17:27
2
Say your parameter $theta$ is a 2-D vector and bounded, i.e., $theta_1 in [a_1, b_1]$ and $theta_2 in [a_2, b_2]$, then $Theta in [a_1, b_1] times [a_2, b_2] $, which is a surface.
– Maxtron
Sep 22 at 18:01